Montgomery Tops List of Least Competitive Insurance Markets
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama controls 90% of the commercial insurance market in Montgomery, Alabama, making it the least competitive metro area in the country, according to the American Medical Association's annual health insurance market competition report.
The AMA examined combined PPO, HMO, POS and exchange enrollment as of Jan. 1, 2025 across 385 metropolitan statistical areas, as reported by Becker's Payer Issues. The analysis is a long-running yardstick the physician group uses to track insurer consolidation and argue that highly concentrated markets give dominant payers leverage over premiums and provider payment rates.
In practice, a single insurer commanding the vast majority of enrollment in a metro limits options for employers and patients and strengthens that payer's bargaining position against hospitals and physicians. The AMA has used these findings for years to oppose large insurer mergers. For executives and investors, the report is a reminder that many local insurance markets remain effectively one-carrier regions, even as national competition narratives suggest otherwise.
Sources